This fall we had a little trial run at kindergarten. Since Ethan was a baby I had planned to start him in kindergarten when he was six. There were many reasons: he has a summer birthday, so he'd be on the young end of his class and I've heard from many an experienced kindergarten teacher that boys need an extra year to settle down and focus on school. Plus starting later makes them a little more mature when they go through all of the subsequent transitions to middle school, high school, college. And philosophically, I think childhood is about imagination, reading stories, making muffins, running around and riding bikes, and I hate the idea of tying kiddos to a desk to practice letter sounds when there is still so much playing to be done.
But when it came time for kindergarten decisions last spring, when Ethan was about to turn 5, I let myself be convinced that he was ready. He's so bright! He behaves so well at preschool! He's so curious! We checked out the Waldorf school, which felt like a lovely fairy playland, but it was too expensive and far away and the teacher didn't work for us. (She grabbed Ethan and yelled at him on our visit day. I know he's a handful, but yikes!). So we went with our local public school. We believe in public education and many neighbors reassured us that it was a great school. They even have an all school sing a long once a week! Sitting in the cafeteria full of kiddos singing "Peace Like a River" was a great way to win me over. We spent weeks prepping Ethan, visiting the playground, talking about the daily routine, buying school supplies and arranging for a much admired neighborhood 8 year old to take care of Ethan on the bus. I adjusted my school schedule to help with the transition.
He had his first scary and exciting day, complete with front porch photos and a crying mama. Jeremy and I stared at each other in disbelief, then enjoyed the quiet.
Ethan came home that day, and every day for the week and a half that we held out, completely walloped. He was practically peeing his pants on the bus because he'd been holding it all afternoon. He was desperately hungry because they "eat" lunch at 11:30 (or in Ethan's case, stare at the hustle and bustle for 20 minutes) and don't eat again until getting home at 3:40. And he was sooo tired. It took an adult completely dedicated to feeding, soothing, guiding him to bed just to make it through the afternoon without huge meltdowns. Ethan loved riding the bus but said Kindergarten was "alot of work", with tons of phonics and math and only 1 hour/day of free choice time and 30 minutes of recess. Not my dream of early childhood education! We tried it for a Jeremy tried hard to negotiate with the teacher about getting him an afternoon snack, or bathroom reminders, or letting Jeremy come hang out during lunch to make him feel more comfortable and actually eat something. No go. Apparently having parents in the school during the day is "not consistent with their goals in kindergarten". Not sure exactly what their goals were but I'm fairly certain they are not the same as my goals, which are to get my kid excited about learning and discovery, to help him feel safe and comfortable, to teach him kindness, and (most importantly for all the other goals) make sure he is well fed and rested.
Everyone I spoke with said it takes a couple of weeks at least to get adjusted to kindergarten and that we should just wait it out. But I couldn't believe that it was worth all the hard work and stress on Ethan to succeed at an academic pursuit (and kindergarten has gotten very academic) that I don't even think is particularly important for him right now. So we pulled him out.
By a stroke of good fortune, as we were debating about calling it quits on kindergarten, we stumbled upon a wonderful, play based,
cooperative preschool that just happened to have an opening in the morning class. The day we visited they were picking tomatoes from their garden and making their own salsa! They also have 3 other five year old boys in the class and require a parent to help out twice a month. Ethan slid right in, with no meltdowns, no stress. Now he spends his mornings playing at school and quiet afternoons at home. We'll try kindergarten again next year.
The First Day of Kindergarten (almost)